Creamy Chicken Noodles

Last Updated on March 10, 2025

January 19, 2024

 

My spin on Creamy Chicken Noodles takes the traditional version to another level by adding some cooked bacon and Romano cheese making sweet, sweet love to your taste buds!  Perfect for the colder months,  serve this when you have friends or family over and everyone will have a smile in less than an hour of cooking time.

A finished pot of creamy chicken noodles in a large Dutch oven on the stovetop.

We have always loved Creamy Chicken Noodles but felt like something was missing.  We made them our way one day and after the first taste test, we knew this recipe was a keeper!

One person left this very kind review on the recipe…

“This chicken recipe is a culinary masterpiece! The combination of flavors is simply divine. From the tender, juicy chicken to the aromatic herbs and spices, every bite is a burst of delight. Plus, it’s so easy to make! This chicken recipe has become a family favorite in no time. Highly recommend trying it out!” – Kawsar

If you are looking for some more easy and delicious comfort food recipes, try this Ranch Beef Stroganoff with Cheese TortelliniLoaded Shepherd’s Pie, or some of my other easy dinner recipes.

Why You’ll Love this Recipe

  • Use Rotisserie Chicken as a shortcut. Save the time of cooking your own chicken by picking up a rotisserie from the grocery.
  • Added Bacon and Romano cheese make a twist on a classic. We all know bacon and cheese make everything better,  try this recipe and you will have confirmation!
  • Ready in less than an hour. With minimal prep, this super comforting dish will be ready in less time than it takes to watch your favorite Netflix show.
  • Great for meal prepping. Make this on Sunday and have delicious leftovers all week!

Ingredients displayed for creamy chicken noodles. Includes noodles, abcon, chicken, spices, celery, romano cheese, cream, condensed soup, carrots, and chicken broth.

Ingredients

  • Rotisserie Chicken- Feel free to cook your won chicken but this is a time saver and I use rotisserie chickens a lot in my dishes.
  • Carrots-  If using fresh they do take a little longer to cook down and soften so feel free to used canned.  That will get these Creamy Chicken Noodles ready even quicker!
  • Celery- 3-4 ribs of celery diced up fairly small
  • Pecorino Romano Cheese- 2 cups grated.  Adds a sharp and salty flavor and really elevates this dish!
  • Cooked bacon- Bacon makes everything better and its no exception here.
  • Minced garlic-  around 3 cloves or as much as your heart desires.  Keeps the vampires away and adds a ton of flavor.
  • Potato Slayer seasoning-  We use this in a lot of savory dishes and on a lot of veggies.  It’s fantastic and readily available at Walmart, Kroger, and Meijer amongst other places.
  • Black Pepper- We put a lot of black pepper in everything.  Feel free to reduce or increase the amount I recommend.
  • Onion powder- You can do diced onion instead but I’m not a fan of onion texture so I used powder bc it does lend some nice flavor.
  • Dried sage-  if using fresh,  use 3/4-1 tsp instead of 1/4 tsp.  Adds a warm, earthy flavor to savory dishes.
  • Dried thyme-  if using fresh,  use 3/4-1 tsp instead of 1/4 tsp.  Adds earthy and citrus notes.
  • Dried rosemary- if using fresh,  use 3/4-1 tsp instead of 1/4 tsp. Adds fragrant, almost lemon like notes.
  • Dried marjoram- if using fresh,  use 3/4-1 tsp instead of 1/4 tsp. Adds fresh, floral flavor.
  • All-purpose Flour- Used to create a roux to thicken the dish.
  • Chicken Stock- I have started using stock as opposed to broth bc it lends a richer flavor.  But,  broth is def fine to use.
  • Cream of Chicken- I like the cream of chicken soup with herbs for more flavor but either works.  If not a fan,  omit it from the recipe…
  • Heavy Cream- Helps make the noodles creamy and rich!
  • Egg Noodles- I use 8 oz most of the time,  sometimes I’ll use 12oz.  Any brand will do…

How to make Creamy Chicken Noodles

  • 1. Cut up and cook bacon in large dutch oven or pan on medium heat.

Bacon is cooking in bottom of Dutch oven.

  • 2. Dice celery post washing, set aside.
  • 3. Grate Romano cheese and set aside.
  • 4. Once bacon is cooked remove and add celery.
  • 5. After 5-6 min lower heat to med-low and add garlic.

Garlic and celery are cooking in the bacon drippings in a large Dutch oven.

  • 6. Add seasonings and stir well. Add flour and continue to stir a min or two for the flour to cook off.

Seasonings for creamy chicken noodles are on a white plate and ready to add into the dutch oven.

  • 7. Add chicken broth, cream of chicken, and carrots.

The carrots, condensed soup, and chicken broth are added to the dutch oven.

  • 8. Now, add egg noodles and allow to continue to simmer covered until soft stirring occasionally. (10-15 min)

Egg noodles are added to the Dutch oven for creamy chicken noodles.

  • 9. Stir in Romano and heavy cream continuing to stir until cheese has melted.  Enjoy!

Grated romano cheese and heavy cream are added to creamy chicken noodles in the Dutch oven last to simmer before enjoying.

Expert Tips

  • Lighten the dish by using Half and Half instead of Heavy Cream. This will reduce the fat content in the chicken and noodles, making it a little lighter.
  • If you don’t want to use the potato slayer seasoning,  substitute 1 tablespoon tomato bouillon, 1/2 teaspoon red pepper flakes, and 1/4 teaspoon dried dill.
  • If you want this dish more soupy,  add more chicken stock.

Storage and Freezing

You can store this in the fridge in an airtight container for 4-5 days.

This can be made ahead of time.  But,  don’t prep the egg noodles until day of serving. Reheat on the stove stop and you can add a little chicken stock to thin out if needed.  Either cook egg noodles separate and add or use a little more chicken stock as they will absorb liquid from the dish.

This is not a dish we recommend freezing. The noodles will be very mushy upon reheating.

A finished pot of creamy chicken noodles in a large Dutch oven ready to serve and made on the stove.

FAQs

Can I use pasta instead of egg noodles? 

Yes,  that would be fine.  Note that pasta may take a little longer to cook than the egg noodles.

Can I leave out the bacon and cheese?

Absolutely, that would make it more traditional.  But,  I’m obviously biased to the way I make it and think it’s a tastier version.

More Comfort Food Recipes

Creamy chicken noodles is being scooped by a ladle from a dutch oven on the stovetop.

Creamy Chicken Noodles

These aren't your momma's chicken noodles! I like to add my own spin on dishes when I Can and we added some Romano cheese and bacon for a huge flavor upgrade! This is the kind of easy meal you want cook up on a cold day and eat in front of the fireplace while watching hallmark movies with you boo. Just kidding, lets watch football instead bc I have the remote! Hope you try these and enjoy them as much as we did. look forward to any feedback you might have in the comment section!
5 from 7 votes
Print Pin Rate
Course: Main Course
Cuisine: American
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 45 minutes
Servings: 6

Ingredients

  • 1 Rotisserie Chicken skin removed, deboned, and shredded
  • 1 can sliced carrots peeled and diced
  • 4 celery diced
  • 2 cups Pecorino Romano Cheese grated
  • 1 lb bacon
  • 3 cloves garlic minced or grated
  • 1 tbsp potato slayer seasoning
  • 1.5 tsp black pepper
  • 1 tsp onion powder
  • 1/4 tsp dried sage
  • 1/4 tsp dried rosemary
  • 1/4 tsp dried thyme
  • 1/4 tsp dried marjoram
  • 1/3 cup AP flour for roux
  • 6 cups chicken broth
  • 1 can Cream of Chicken w/herbs preferably
  • 1/2 cup heavy cream
  • salt to taste
  • 8 oz egg noodles

Instructions

  • Cut up and cook bacon in large dutch oven or pan on medium heat.
  • Dice celery post washing, set aside.
  • Grate Romano cheese and set aside.
  • Once bacon is cooked remove and add celery.
  • After 5-6 min lower heat to med-low and add garlic.
  • Add seasonings and stir well. Add flour and continue to stir a min or two for the flour to cook off.
  • Add chicken broth, cream of chicken, and carrots.
  • Bring to a simmer, add chicken and bacon.
  • Now, add egg noodles and allow to continue to simmer covered until soft stirring occasionally. (10-15 min) Enjoy!!
  • Stir in Romano and heavy cream continuing to stir. Enjoy!

Video

Notes

As always,  there are ways to make this easier....  You can sub bacon pieces for the bacon and use your favorite oil instead of bacon grease although I feel you will be sacrificing flavor.  Feel free to add onion with the carrots/celery,  we just aren't big onion fans so I left it out.  If you don't like cream of chicken,  omit it but it adds flavor and creaminess!  Lastly,  you can sub pre grated cheese for the Romano,  Parm or asiago would both be great in my opinion!

27 Comments

  1. September Board

    5 stars
    Very flavorful and hit the spot on a cold day!

    Reply
  2. Bethany

    5 stars
    I omitted the carrots and celery, (am a 43 yr old woman child who doesn’t like vegetables), but did everything else as instructed. Nom nom nom! Thank you!

    Reply
    • Matt Ramsey

      Awesome!

      Reply
  3. KarenB

    I’m looking forward to making this, but is there any substitute for the Potato Slayer seasoning? I swear that is about the only seasoning I currently don’t have.

    Reply
    • Matt Ramsey

      You could leave it out, it just has a unique flavor protocol.

      Reply
  4. Sharon Wooding

    I’m going to to make this but wondering where you get the potato slayer seasoning? It’s look so good. Thanks!

    Reply
    • Matt Ramsey

      I get it at Walmart!

      Reply
  5. Kristie Sawatzky

    According to their website Potato Slayer is Cayenne Pepper and Tarragon), Tomato Powder, Paprika, Apple Cider Vinegar Powder (Maltodextrin, Apple Cider Vinegar, and Food Starch-modified), Dill Weed, and Not More Than 2% Tricalcium Phosphate Added To Prevent Caking.

    ***Our family loves this soup…we sometimes add a 1/2 cup of cooking sherry to the leftovers for a new twist the second meal/time around.
    My family of 5 thinks this soup is amazing and served with cheesy and garlic Hawaiian rolls. This soup has a very Italian feel compared to a traditional chicken noodle soup.
    We also use frozen Reames Homestyle Egg Noodles (2) 12oz. bags or 1 24oz. Quick Prep.
    Thank you, for sharing, much love to your soup.

    Reply
    • Matt Ramsey

      Thank you!

      Reply
    • Debbie

      Can I use regular milk, if I don’t have heavy cream?

      Reply
    • Roxanne

      Thanks for help. Can’t wait to but it together¡

      Reply
  6. Joyce

    This was really good. I saw it and thought I have to try this. I figured the only thing I didn’t think I had was the Potato Slayer. Never heard of it but I saw I could get it at Walmart so I picked it up. I went to make it and found that I didn’t have marjoram looked it up and oregano is a good substitute. Such a tasty dish. Really liked this will definitely make it again. Everyone went in for a second helping. I’ll be looking up more of your recipes.

    Reply
    • Matt Ramsey

      Love to hear it

      Reply
    • Sue Grimes

      Made it…WOW…
      LOVE IT!!

      Reply
  7. Lisa M Lyons

    5 stars
    Is potato slayer seasoning available anywhere?

    Reply
    • Matt Ramsey

      I get it at WalMart but my local Kroger also has it!

      Reply
  8. Dyan

    I made it! I actually made it and it is amazing! Thank.

    Reply
  9. Jacquelyn E.

    Tuned out great!

    Reply
    • Matt Ramsey

      🙌

      Reply
  10. Shelley Deiter

    5 stars
    I made this today. It was fantastic. I don’t cook often, I would make this a lot. I didn’t have the potatoe slayer, so I used Dan’os.

    Reply
  11. paval

    5 stars
    Chiken Noodles a timeless favorite that captivates with its savory allure. From the first whiff of aromatic broth to the last slurp of tender Chiken Noodles, each bite is a culinary adventure. Whether enjoyed steaming hot on a chilly day or chilled for a refreshing summer treat, it’s a versatile dish that always hits the spot. A true comfort classic!”

    Reply
    • Matt Ramsey

      Nice!

      Reply
    • Matt Ramsey

      🙌

      Reply
    • LaQuida

      Saw this recipe on Instagram and wanted to try it out. It was a hit. Thanks!

      Reply
      • Matt Ramsey

        Thank you!

        Reply
  12. NCRN50

    5 stars
    Made this tonite. Delicious, definitely a keeper. This isn’t health food but it’s definitely comfort food! I did use onion cause I’m a devout believer in the holy trinity of onion carrot celery with chicken dishes. The Potato Slayer is not available in my area so I used a chicken grill seasoning that contains all the main seasonings in the Potato Slayer. I deglazed my Dutch oven twice with a little broth during the cooking process and ended up with a divine base. Try this one out, it’s great!

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Filter by Categories
Recipes
Appetizers
Beef
Breakfast
Casserole
Chicken
Dessert
Dinner
Fish
Pasta
Potatoes
Side Dishes
Sliders
Snacks
Sandwiches

Categories

Archives

You Might Also Like

AppetizersDinnerSnacks
Pepperoni Rolls

Pepperoni Rolls

Pepperoni Rolls Easy to make and always a crowd pleaser! 1 tube pillsbury pizza dough8 slices mozzarella cheese24 large pepperonis1 egg(for wash)4 tbsp melted butteritalian seasoninggarlic powdergrated parmesan cheese Preheat oven to 425 degrees. Roll out pizza...